In the media? It can matter

Those who took part in the audit of public records access in Arizona were instructed to identify themselves by name but, if possible, avoid disclosing they were journalists.

The reason was concern that journalists, who regularly seek public records, would receive treatment different from what an ordinary citizen would receive.

So do they? Yes and no, according to two examples from the audit:

* In South Tucson, an auditor from the Arizona Daily Star signed for a bicycle theft report that was stamped, she later learned, "not intended for disclosure to the press or other news media."

* In Globe, a reporter from The Arizona Republic was recognized by a former source at the Police Department and, after encountering some resistance while seeking documents, was quickly given what he sought. The official said things would have gone better if he'd identified himself as a journalist.

Safford Police Chief Dennis Thompson said reluctance among police departments to release public records stems from their mistrust of journalists.

"We have a feeling that the news media is out to rip us," Thompson said. "They are trying to find fault."